The mathematics of public services
I would like to share some objective observations on the characteristics and costs of public services, while steering clear of ideological or political issues and complicated economic theories. Public services are a fundamental component of modern states, as they operate in sectors of primary importance to citizens, such as healthcare, education, public safety, and the management of public infrastructure. Public administration (PA) expenditures are covered by general taxation—that is, by taxes paid by the public. Most countries offer a more or less extensive range of public services, and it is difficult for us to imagine a society without them. So let’s start at the beginning.
What is the essence of public service?
The following story illustrates the concept in a simple way, free of unnecessary complexity. Imagine an island with 10 families, each with one child and one elderly parent. Imagine also that the island’s economy is very simple, and that the only activity people engage in is related to food production (fishing, fruit gathering, farming, and livestock raising). At some point, the community decides that two of the ten families should devote themselves entirely to caring for the children and the elderly, thereby establishing the island’s first public service. Let us assume that the existing agreement provides that the two “public service” families receive the same amount of food they previously obtained themselves. If each family’s food requirement is 100 units, this means that the eight taxpayer families must produce 125 units of food each: 100 for their own needs and 25 as their share of the needs of the two public-service families. Therefore, the tax rate applied to income is 25/125 = 20%.
Simple as it is, this little story highlights some key characteristics of public service:
- It is based on a contract of mutual trust between taxpayers and public employees.
- There is no difference in importance between the two categories of workers; both satisfy essential needs of the community.
- Public services cannot exist without the contribution of non-public-sector workers. This provides a concrete illustration of how, in a modern society, the public and private sectors are inherently interconnected and indispensable in ensuring the well-being of the community.
According to data provided by ARAN (an Italian Agency related to Public Administrations), Italy’s expenditure on salaries and social contributions for public employees (central and local administrations and social security institutions) amounted to approximately €178.6 billion in 2024, compared with €170.9 billion in 2023, an annual increase of 4.5%. The issue is not so much whether this figure is high or low in itself. As the island example clearly shows, what is essential for the sustainability of public finances is that public expenditure be covered by general taxation. With regard to this balance, what can we say about a 4.5% annual increase in public-sector wage expenditure when, during the same period, GDP grew by only about 0.7% (source: ISTAT, the official italian institute providing national statistics)? This does not necessarily imply a public-finance imbalance, but it does suggest that maintaining financial equilibrium requires careful budget management in order to avoid repercussions on the deficit and public debt.
But let us return to our island. After some time, the arrival of a parasite reduces the food supply by 20%. What effect does this have on the community’s life? The eight taxpayer families will now produce a total of 1,000 units, compared with the previous total of 1,250. Under the existing agreement, the two “public service” families will continue to receive the same amount of food, namely 100 units each, guaranteed by the 25 units contributed by every taxpayer family. In this situation, however, each taxpayer family would see its own income fall from 100 to 75 units, a reduction of 25%.
Returning to the analogy with the real world, this example, despite its simplicity, illustrates a very important issue concerning the sustainability of public services, one that became dramatically evident during the COVID-19 pandemic. When an event reduces the earnings of private-sector workers, leading to lower tax revenues, the rigidity of public-sector wages translates into expenditure that is not fully covered by revenue, resulting in a deficit and, consequently, public debt. Once again, this is not a matter of ideology, politics, or opinion. It is pure mathematics. Re-examining the nature of public service from this perspective could help not only to reduce the almost existential conflict between private-sector and public-sector workers, but also to prevent, at the outset, utopian proposals for uncontrolled increases in public-sector employment, as though such measures came at no cost.
In conclusion, a few days ago I listened to a speech by Milena Gabanelli, a highly popular and competent italian journalist. Her argument was the following: every time we receive a public service free of charge, the provider should give us a notional invoice showing the economic value of that service. This actually happened to me once. Among the medical documents I received after my son underwent hand surgery, I found a notional invoice for approximately €1,600. Imagine if this happened with every public service we use: not only every doctor’s appointment or hospital treatment, but also services carried out without our direct involvement, such as school maintenance, road maintenance, or the upkeep of public green spaces. Like Milena Gabanelli, I am convinced that very few people would then be tempted to regard taxes as nothing more than an excessive and useless burden imposed by an overbearing state.
You can send your comment to info@esperienzedivalore.it, I will be happy to respond.